AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Unlikely Pair

Page 154

by Chelle Sloan

“But…”

I let out a sigh. “But they’re my family. And even though I know they’re toxic, it’s still my family. Maybe it’s the eldest daughter in me who thinks it’s my job to keep everything together. Or to be the one to keep trying. I don’t know. Part of me is hoping they want to apologize. At least be civil since they’ll be in my life because of Rob. I don’t know.” I shake my head and shrug. “Maybe part of me just wants to know what they have to say. Is it wrong to hope it’ll give me some sort of closure?”

“You’re a good person, Sutton,” Gabi says, giving me a side hug. “And no, it’s not.”

“Probably too good,” I admit. “But I’m holding my ground. I’m just going to hear what they have to say, and if it’s more bullshit, I’m out.”

“You just give me the signal and I’ll throw them out myself.”

“Nope. That’s going to be my job.”

Gabi and I look up to see Shelby walking in, wearing a baseball cap and sunglasses.

“What’s with the getup?”

“What? These?” she says as she takes off her aviators. “How else am I supposed to spy if I don’t have a disguise?”

“You’re here to spy?” I mean, I’m well aware my life is entertaining in a reality-show kind of way. I just didn’t expect people to give up their afternoons to watch.

“You think I’m missing this?” she says. “From what I’ve heard about your family? I needed to see this for myself.”

“How did you find out?”

“My big-mouth husband,” she says, taking a seat in the booth across from me. “Asher told the guys at poker last night. Something about maybe needing bail money if things happened. You know, for a group of pro athletes, they sure do love to gossip.”

“They really do,” I agree with a laugh. “Also, question. On these poker nights, do your men come home with baked goods every time?”

This takes both of them by surprise.

“I think I’d notice that,” Shelby says, tilting her head and pursing her lips. “There does always seems to be a fresh loaf of sour dough in the house the day after poker. That might be a coincidence, though. He says he gets it from a market on his way to meet the guys. I don’t have a reason to think he’s lying, but now that you mention it, the timing is suspicious.”

“Wait,” Gabi says, holding her finger up like she’s having a lightbulb moment. “Maddox always does have things. Says he grabbed them from the bakery for the guys, and that there were leftovers. But last time there were cookies that I know I’ve never made.”

The three of us try to put the pieces together, but before any one of us can come up with an answer, I see two bleach-blonde figures wearing matching hot pink gym sets walking toward the bakery.

“They’re here,” I say, shooing Shelby from the table.

“Okay, I’m going to sit over there. Pretend I’m working. But just know I’m totally eavesdropping, and maybe recording in case this ends up in some sort of legal battle.”

“Just face the other way,” I say. “I know them and I know you. The first dumb thing my sister says and you aren’t going to be able to hide your reaction, which will make me laugh.”

“Deal,” Shelby says. “So I can prepare, do they really wear matching outfits?”

“See for yourself.”

On cue, Mom and Angelina walk into the bakery, and I wonder if I need to put on my own sunglasses to be able to look at them. The combination of their fake tans, their outfits, and their hair…well…it’s just a lot. Also, I don’t know if they rehearsed this or if it’s a product of how much time they spend together, but they slide their Gucci sunglasses to the top of their heads in unison.

Wonder if Rob knows how much he spent on those?

“Mom. Angelina.”

I don’t stand up to greet them. I don’t offer a hug. I stay firmly in my seat, my hands on my lap, because I refuse to open any doors in this conversation. They’re lucky I’m talking to them at all.

“Sutton. You look well.”

I can’t tell if Mom is serious with that comment, so I don’t respond to it. “What do you want, Mother?”

“What? No pleasantries? No catching up?”