AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Unlikely Pair

Page 63

by Chelle Sloan

“You’re probably wondering why I asked you here today,” he says.

“The question did cross my mind.”

Asher grabs the water Gabi brought for him, cupping it with both of his hands. I immediately push aside thoughts of just how big his hands are, because he’s already said this isn’t a date, and this man looks stressed. Last thing he needs is me ogling his hands.

“Is everything okay?” I ask, suddenly worried that something might’ve happened with…Adalyn? His Mom? Did he get in trouble after the fight?

“Yeah. Everything is fine,” he says. “Well, the big stuff is fine. It’s…well…I got this idea.”

“Okay. Do you want to tell me about it?”

He opens his mouth to start talking, closing and opening it about three times before he suddenly pushes up from the booth. “This was a mistake. I’m sorry I asked you here. I should just go.”

“Whoa!” I cry out, hurrying and grabbing his hand as he starts to walk away. “How about you slow down. Take a few breaths. Plus, you can’t walk away and leave me hanging. My FOMO will drive me insane, and it’ll be your fault when I completely lose touch with reality.”

“But it’s a stupid idea,” he says as he reluctantly sits back down. “I’m going to blame it on a crazy travel schedule, not a lot of sleep, annoying friends, and my mother.”

“That’s quite the combination.”

“They’ve driven me to the brink of insanity,” he says, grabbing a napkin and nervously shredding it. “Which is why I’m now debating asking you this. As I was walking in, I thought this was the best idea in the world. But now that I’m thinking about it, now that you’re here, I’m just going to pretend it never crossed my mind.”

“Well now I have to know,” I say. “You can’t dangle that carrot and not expect me to chase it.”

Asher does look exhausted. Handsome, but exhausted. “You don’t know what you’re potentially getting into. And, the more I think about it, the more I wonder if my mom spiked my sleepy-time tea.”

“You keep trying to scare me away, but you keep sweetening the pot,” I say, leaning in closer to him. “You can say it quietly. That way your secret will be safe with me. Along with the secret that you drink sleepy-time tea.”

He lets out a big breath. “I warned you.”

“Noted. Spill.”

He swallows a lump in his throat before leaning in, the two of us so close I can smell his cologne and feel his breath on my cheek. Which is the reason why I’m lightheaded when I hear words I never imagined I’d ever hear from Asher Reed—or anyone else on planet Earth.

“Sutton…will you pretend to be my girlfriend?”

CHAPTER 15

ASHER

Fuck. I said it.

Out loud.

With my mouth.

How on God’s green earth did I think this was a good idea? Am I so sleep-deprived, and so tired from the season, and so over everyone butting into my life, that it led me to thinking that asking Sutton to be my fake girlfriend was a good idea?

Apparently so, because I just did.

And I think I’ve put her into a coma.

“See? Horrible idea,” I quickly say. “Please forget what I said and let's just have some pie or a cinnamon roll. My treat. Would you like a whole pie? Gabi would give you a whole pie. Or a whole tray of cinnamon rolls. Whichever you’d like, let me order it for you and then we can eat it and be so full we’ll forget that I’m a dumbass.”

When I’m done rambling—which I’ve never done in my adult or adolescent life—the silence is thick again, save for my breathing, because I don’t think I took a single breath during that speech.

But that’s only until Sutton’s laughter is so loud it echoes off the walls. And I’m pretty sure it gives Phyllis and Kitty a heart attack.

“What’s so funny?”