AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Falling for Christmas

Page 25

by Carly Phillips

It’s a clear dismissal, and I hate it. I want to stay, to argue playfully about stupid holiday décor and flirt and drink her hot chocolate. I want to kiss her and make her forget that I was such an asshole. But that doesn’t seem possible at the moment. I need to respect that she doesn’t want to talk to me right now.

I incline my head. “I’ll go. But I’m going to make this up to you.”

She doesn’t acknowledge my words as she takes a seat on her couch and picks up a piece of paper, her attention already on her work. Or she’s pretending. It doesn’t matter. The result is the same. She’s frozen me out. It hurts, even if I deserve it.

With that depressing thought in mind, I leave her house, walking right past the cheery decorations she’s put up outside both of our homes.

I’ll give her space tonight and hopefully, she’ll forgive me by tomorrow.

CHAPTER THIRTEEN

Clay

I’m in a shitty mood as I sign yet another Wranglers hat. I’m not sure how many I’ve signed so far, but it feels like hundreds. I started with shirts and jerseys, then moved on to my photograph, and now, hats. My hand is cramping, but that’s not the reason for my bad mood.

I glance at my phone lying face up on the table, silently willing Holly to text me back. I’ve sent a dozen messages to her today, and she hasn’t replied to a single one. First, I apologized again for being such an asshole yesterday. Then, I tried to find out her exact plans for this evening, where she would be shopping, what time, and whether she got someone else to help her with the task since I let her down.

She didn’t respond at all, which I deserve.

Next, I tried to sending her friendly messages like we’ve done ever since the night she messaged to tell me I played a great game. I’m desperate for us to go back to normal, but she’s not replying. I try telling myself she’s probably been busy. She’s already told me the end of the semester is hectic, and I know she’s out shopping right now.

Without me.

I’m sure she’s still upset I let her down.

“Man, I wish I hadn’t let my agent talk me into this,” Greg sighs as he finishes scrawling his name with a Sharpie on the last football in the bin by his side. “But the twins are sixteen and wanted cars for Christmas, so I agreed to do it.”

Lee shakes out his hand. “At least you have a good reason. I was in the middle of working out when my agent called me, and you know what I’m like when I’m in the zone. Total focus. I just agreed to what the guy said without really paying attention.”

Greg laughs and looks at me. “What about you, Clay? You have nothing better to do tonight?”

Yes, I really did have something better to do. I think about Holly giving up her whole evening to buy toys for kids that might not receive anything for Christmas without her. She wants them to experience some of the joy that she associates with the holiday. It’s such a kind thing to do, and I should be with her. Like I promised.

I let the guilt seep into my bones, refusing to give in to the instinct to make excuses for my decision to be here instead. That urge is exactly why I told my Christmas-loving girl that it’s an empty, commercialism-driven holiday. I didn’t want to face this feeling of guilt. Somehow, I know I regret letting Holly down more than if I’d bailed on tonight.

“I shouldn’t have agreed to do this at all,” I admit.

There’s a moment of awkward silence before Lee pats me on the back. “Well, now you know for next time.”

I nod, but I can’t stop myself from thinking that when it comes to Holly, I might not get a next time at all.

I finish signing the last of my merch, say my goodbyes to the guys, and leave right away. Did I bond with them? Yeah, about not wanting to be where we were. Was it worth letting Holly down? Fuck, no.

Arriving home, Holly’s house is dark. It’s late. I’d hoped she’d be home from shopping by now. Knowing that she’s probably still out taking care of it alone only increases my guilt. Walking into my own home, I check my phone again, not surprised to see she still hasn’t responded.

I’ll have to try to talk to her in person tomorrow.

CHAPTER FOURTEEN

Holly

I survived the week, but I’m exhausted all the way down to my bones. After Clay bailed on shopping, I knew that this was going to be a rough week. I asked Madison to join me, but she had a date.

The Wish List came from my sister’s replacement at the charity where she worked when she still lived in Charleston, and the corporate sponsor donated enough money for me to buy multiples of everything on the list. I honestly believe that even if we don’t get a ton of actual toy donations, we’ll still have an impressive amount of fun gifts to give to the children.

It’s all great, but it was a lot of shopping to handle on my own. Visiting several stores, filling up carts, hauling bags from the store to my car, and from my car to inside my house was a lot of work, but I managed.

I had the last week before the holidays at school. The kids are always hyped up this time of year, and the days were long. Then I stayed late on Thursday, finishing my final grades, preparing for the holiday party the next day, and avoiding Clay’s increasingly frequent text messages.