Page 33

Maggie offered a faint, grateful smile, her shoulders relaxing slightly as she squeezed his hand.

“But I want to be entirely clear about one thing,” Ben added, his voice strong and uncompromising. “I’m not looking for a temporary holiday comfort. I won’t be a seasonal companion who disappears when the Christmas decorations go back into the attic boxes, and I won’t enter a relationship that has a built-in expiration date.”

Maggie looked at him, her eyes widening slightly as the full weight of his words settled into her mind. There was no hesitation or doubt in his posture. Ben was standing before her as a whole man, ready to build a real, lasting future with her if she chose to walk beside him.

“I don’t want an expiration date either,” Maggie murmured, her voice full of sincere warmth.

Ben smiled, a genuine, unrestrained joy lighting him up as he gently raised her hand and pressed a lingering kiss to her knuckles. “Good. Then we’ll build this the same way I build a proper dory. One plank at a time, making sure every seam is tight before we put it out into the water.”

Maggie let out a happy laugh, leaning her forehead against his chest for a brief, sweet moment as the winter sun shone brightly through the church windows.

From the side hall, Theo’s joyful voice echoed as he and his friend carried the empty cocoa cups back toward the kitchen doors. Ben let go of Maggie’s hand with a subtle nod, picking up the dry loaf pan to set it on the pantry shelf, his heart feeling at peace, completely ready for whatever lay ahead.

MAGGIE

As the following Tuesday drifted further into the evening, Cranberry Harbor had turned an icy blue as cold sea wind swept across the salt marsh grass near the boatyard. Weathered gray cedar shingles covered the exterior of Foster Woodworks, where tall multi-paned windows glowed with warm yellow light against the gathering winter twilight.

Maggie arrived at the heavy double doors of the shop, excitement at seeing Ben again making her movements quick and sure. He had mentioned that Theo was spending the afternoon at a friend’s house, so he’d be working late at his shop and invited her to stop by.

She reached out, turning the brass door handle and stepping inside as the small iron chime above the frame rang against the wood.

The shop interior was warm, quiet, and filled with the comforting aroma of red cedar, linseed oil, and beeswax. High timber rafters spanned the ceiling, hung with wooden boat oars, iron C-clamps, and coils of copper wire. On the wide pine floorboards below, clean sweeps of pale sawdust lined the pathways between the band saws and workbenches.

Ben sat on a sturdy wooden stool at his central workbench beneath a low-hanging brass lamp. He wore a dark sweater with sleeves pushed up to his forearms, holding a small block of red cedar in his left hand and a narrow woodcarving knife in his right. His tall frame was leaning forward over the bench, completely absorbed in shaping the wood.

Maggie hung her coat on the peg near the doorway, placing her bag on the bench seat before approaching the worktable. “Good afternoon,” she greeted him fondly.

Ben looked up, his eyes softening with genuine pleasure as he set the carving knife down on a leather tool mat. “Good afternoon. I didn’t hear your car pull onto the gravel.”

“The wind is blowing hard today, drowning out a lot of outside noise,” Maggie replied, pulling up a wooden stool beside the bench and sitting down. She looked at the object resting in his palm. “What are you carving?”

Ben looked at the red cedar block. It was a half-finished songbird, roughly four inches long, its sharp crest and curved beak meticulously shaped from the rich reddish wood. The head and chest were smooth and defined, but the left wing remained rough and unformed, showing fine pencil lines mapped out across the grain. A jagged broken piece left the unfinished wing with a small notch.

“It’s a northern cardinal,” Ben explained, his deep voice dropping an octave as his thumb smoothed the bird’s crest. “I started carving it last winter before Ruth passed away. She loved watching the red birds getting into the winter berries near the porch feeder, so I picked up a block of red cedar from the mill and started shaping the crest on silent evenings.”

Maggie looked at the half-finished bird resting under the yellow lamplight. “Why didn’t you finish it?”

Ben set the carving down on a white cotton towel between them. “When she got sick, I put the carving tools away. After the funeral, I opened the bench drawer to grab a pair of pliers and saw the unfinished wing sitting beside the sandpaper. Touching it felt like trying to hold onto an afternoon that was already gone. So I wrapped it in a towel and shoved it into the back of the drawer.”

He stared at the small cedar bird, his broad chest rising and falling with a slow, even breath. “I pulled it out twenty minutes ago. I thought a year of sitting in a dark drawer was long enough for a red bird.”

Maggie looked at the half-carved cardinal, a poignant resonance stirring in her chest. She reached out, her fingers lightly brushing the edge of the cotton towel.

“I have a notebook in my sideboard drawer,” Maggie confessed, her eyes meeting his in the shop light. “It’s a small leather book that my late husband bought at the stationery shop in town for our fifth anniversary.”

Ben listened attentively, resting his forearms on the workbench. “What’s written inside it?”

“It was our travel notebook,” Maggie explained, a bittersweet smile touching her lips. “Every winter, we sat by the fire and wrote down a list of coastal towns we wanted to visit during the summer season. We mapped out lighthouse tours along the Maine shore, bed and breakfast inns in Vermont, and small harbor villages up in Nova Scotia. We checked off six or seven places over the years.”

She paused, her fingers tracing the hem of her sweater cuff. “The last entry was written in October, right before he got sick. We’d planned a two-week trip along the coast to see the autumn leaves and visit the maritime museum in Mystic. We had the dates written down, the bed and breakfast reserved, and a list of seafood dinners mapped out on the page.”

“And you never went,” Ben finished gently, his tone full of absolute understanding.

“I canceled the reservation just days after the funeral,” Maggie whispered. “And I put the notebook into the bottom drawer under the linen tablecloths. Every time I looked at those unchecked boxes, I felt like finishing the trip without him would be pretending that he didn’t matter, or that I could just replace our plans with a solo drive.”

Ben reached out, his rough fingers picking up the half-carved cardinal. He held the smooth red wood into the soft light of the lamp, examining the rough pencil lines on the unfinished wing.

“I used to think that way too,” Ben said, his tone steady. “I thought leaving things unfinished was a monument to loyalty, as if keeping a bird half-carved or a notebook closed proved how much we loved them. But sitting in this shop today, looking at this cedar block, I realize we had it backwards.”