Page 122
Delaney lifts her head, her eyebrows drawing together as she considers my explanation. "People took that?"
"Yes."
"From space?"
"That's right."
She looks back at the photograph, then turns toward the kitchen, where Felix is making coffee. "Felix, did you know people have been in space?"
Felix glances over his shoulder, a smile spreading across his face. "I did, sweetheart."
"Why didn't you tell me?"
"Because I didn't know you wanted to know," Felix replies, setting his mug on the counter. "There are quite a few things we haven't had a chance to talk about yet."
Delaney appears to consider that a reasonable explanation before returning her attention to me. "Why did people go into space?"
I explain the scientific and technological motivations behind space exploration, including the competition between the United States and the Soviet Union during the twentieth century. She listens without interrupting, although her eyes move repeatedly between my face and the photograph. When I finish, she studies the image for several more seconds before asking a question I hadn't anticipated. "Did they find God?"
Behind me, Felix coughs into his coffee. I keep my attention on Delaney, recognizing that her question is entirely reasonable given the beliefs she was raised with. "No," I explain. "The astronauts didn't find evidence of God on the moon."
Her forehead creases. "But Father said heaven was above us."
"Many religious traditions describe heaven that way," I reply. "However, people interpret those descriptions differently. Some understand heaven as a spiritual existence rather than a physical place somewhere beyond the clouds."
"Do you believe that?"
I consider my response carefully. Delaney has spent most of her life being told what she's required to believe, and I have no intention of replacing one unquestionable authority with another. "My personal beliefs aren't particularly important to today's lesson," I explain. "I'm here to help you understand the information available so you can develop your own opinions."
She looks dissatisfied. "But if you know more than me, shouldn't I believe what you believe?"
"Not necessarily. Someone can possess a great deal of knowledge and still be mistaken about certain things. It's important to examine evidence and understand why we believe something rather than accepting it simply because another person tells us to."
Delaney studies me with an expression I find difficult to interpret. "Father didn't like questions," she eventually says.
"I imagine that made learning rather difficult."
She looks down at the photograph. "He said questions were a sign of doubt, and doubt was the beginning of disobedience."
I take a moment before answering. "In this classroom, questions are encouraged. You won't be punished for asking them, and I won't expect you to agree with everything I say."
She nods, although I suspect understanding that intellectually will be considerably easier than believing it. I turn to a diagram illustrating Earth's geological history. "Now, scientists estimate that Earth formed approximately 4.54 billion years ago."
Delaney looks up sharply. "That's wrong."
"Which part?"
"The number. Earth can't be that old because God created it."
"All right," I reply, keeping my tone conversational. "Let's examine how scientists arrived at that estimate."
I introduce radiometric dating, explaining how radioactive elements decay at predictable rates and how scientists use those processes to estimate the ages of rocks. I show her diagrams of geological strata and explain how evidence from Earth and meteorites contributes to our understanding of the planet's age. Delaney follows the explanation carefully, occasionally asking me to clarify unfamiliar terminology. She appears particularly interested in the idea that scientists can determine the age of something without having witnessed its formation.
When I finish, I lean back in my chair. "What do you think about that, Delaney?"
Her expression changes. She looks down at the textbook, then back at me, her fingers beginning to move against the fabric of her dress. "What do you mean?"
"I'm interested in your thoughts about the evidence we've discussed."