Page 123
"Is it true?"
"The scientific evidence strongly supports it."
"Then that's the answer."
"That's the current scientific understanding," I clarify. "But I'm interested in what you make of the information."
Her thumb begins rubbing against the side of her index finger, the movement becoming increasingly rapid. "I don't know."
"That's perfectly acceptable. You don't have to know everything after one lesson."
"But you asked me."
"I did."
"And I don't know what you want me to say."
I pause, noticing the tension gathering in her shoulders. "There isn't a particular answer I'm expecting."
She shakes her head. "There has to be."
"Why do you think that?"
"Because you're teaching me." Her voice becomes quieter. "You're supposed to know the answers, and I'm supposed to give you the right ones."
I begin to understand the problem. "Delaney, when I ask what you think, I'm not necessarily testing whether you've remembered the information correctly. Sometimes I'm asking whether you have questions, whether you agree with an explanation, or whether there's something you'd like to explore further."
"But what if I disagree with you?"
"Then I'd like to understand why."
"What if I'm wrong?"
"Then we can examine the evidence together."
She shakes her head more forcefully, her breathing becoming shallow. "Please just tell me what I'm supposed to think."
There's a difference between a student becoming frustrated because they don't understand an academic concept and a student becoming frightened because they don't know which response will keep them safe. I've encountered the former countless times. I'm beginning to suspect I'm witnessing the latter. "Delaney," I say gently, "there isn't a correct opinion you need to give me."
She glances toward the kitchen, and I follow her gaze to find Felix watching us with concern. "Sweetheart?" Felix asks, setting his mug down. "What's going on?"
Delaney looks at him, her fingers twisting together in her lap. "I don't know the answer."
Felix approaches the couch, crouching beside her so he can see her face. "That's okay. You're here to learn, remember? You don't have to know everything already."
"But Alden keeps asking me what I think."
Felix glances toward me, and I recognize the question in his expression. "I believe I've asked her to do something without explaining it adequately," I admit.
Delaney looks between us, appearing increasingly distressed. "I'm sorry."
"There's nothing to apologize for," I assure her.
I close the textbook, but the movement makes her flinch, and I regret not warning her before doing so. "Would you like to take a break?" I ask.
She looks toward Felix. "Can we?"
"Of course, sweetheart," he replies. "Why don't you come get something to drink?"