AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Holiday Pen Pal Twist

Page 22

by Becca Fall

I frowned slightly, not entirely joking now. Did she really think that? Did I come off as so consistently critical that anything positive coming out of my mouth felt out of character?

“Cassie.”

She didn’t look up immediately, finishing a careful line of green frosting before finally lifting her eyes to mine.

I kept our eyes locked, making sure she was paying attention.

“You’re good at everything you do,” I said, the words coming out more directly than I had planned. “I’m just bad at saying it out loud. If I haven’t told you that before, then you should know I’ve thought it. A lot.”

“Thanks, Alex,” she said, quieter now.

“I mean it,” I added. “You could sell those.”

She stilled for a second, her fingers tightening slightly around the piping bag before she set it down on the table with deliberate care.

Then she looked at me again, this time with a different kind of attention.

“I have a small business,” she said, like she was choosing to keep the tone casual even though the information itself wasn’t. “I do baking pop-ups around the city. Mostly weekends. Holiday markets, events like that.”

“Wow.”

The word came out before I filtered it. I realized, belatedly, that I had stopped what I was doing entirely. The piping bag hung loosely in my hand, forgotten.

“What’s the name of your business?”

“Cassie’s Crumbs.”

“I like it.”

Her eyebrows lifted slightly. “You do?”

“It fits,” I said. “It sounds like something people would remember.”

“Well, thank you. My goal is to be memorable.”

“You succeeded,” I said on instinct, turning away to avoid seeing her expression.

I picked up my cookie with more care than a thing this ugly needed. It remained the most unremarkable cookie on the table, a smooth, white reindeer with no distinguishing features and no apparent sense of purpose.

Cassie finished her last cookie quickly, adding the final details. She set the piping bag down and stood, gathering her plate in one practiced sweep.

“Come on.” She pointed at me. “We need to put these on the drying table before someone decides to eat them.”

I followed her across the room, stepping around clusters of coworkers who had formed loose circles of conversation, the volume rising and falling in pockets as people compared designs and laughed at each other’s attempts. Festive music played quietly in the background.

The drying table was set up along the far wall, already crowded with cookies in various stages of completion. Some were intricate, carefully detailed to the point of being almost professional. Mostly Cassie’s. Honestly, no one could compete against her.

Cassie set her plate down and transferred her cookies with care, adjusting the position of one slightly, rotating it by a fraction of an inch until it sat exactly where she wanted it, then stepping back to assess the overall effect.

I placed my single cookie beside her stack.

She looked at it.

Then she looked at me.

“Alex,” she said, in a tone that was calm enough to be concerning, “you are missing the most crucial part of your cookie.”

I glanced down at it, tilting my head.