AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Holiday Pen Pal Twist

Page 23

by Becca Fall

“I decorated a cookie,” I said. “It’s covered in frosting. I think I’ve met the basic requirements.”

“It doesn’t have a red nose.”

“It doesn’t need one.”

“It’s Rudolph.”

“It’s a reindeer.”

“It’s Rudolph,” she repeated, with the patience of someone explaining something to a child who was choosing not to understand. “Haven’t you heard the song?”

“I’m familiar with the concept,” I said. “I just don’t see why the nose is essential.”

She reached for a piping bag filled with red frosting from the supply table behind us.

“You disgrace Rudolph,” she said.

“I’m not fixing it.”

Cassie stepped closer, closing the space between us.

“Just one dot,” she said, holding up the piping bag like it was a perfectly reasonable solution to a problem I didn’t believe existed. “That’s all I’m asking.”

“I don’t care,” I said again. Half the fun in our arguments was seeing Cassie get riled up. Her eyes got brighter, her mouth pressed into a determined line, and the prettiest shade of pink crept into her cheeks.

“I care,” she shot back. “Which is enough for both of us.”

I shook my head, but she was committed now, guiding the piping bag toward the cookie with focused intent. I reacted on instinct, reaching out to stop her, our hands colliding midair as we both tried to take control of the same small, unnecessary decision.

“Cassie—”

“Alex—”

The cookie shifted under the pressure as her wrist bumped mine. My hand closed more securely around the piping bag as we pulled it back and forth between us.

For a brief second, we were both focused on the same point, the same ridiculous, insignificant detail, our attention narrowed to the exact spot where the red frosting was about to land.

And then everything went wrong.

Someone brushed past behind me, catching the edge of my shoulder just enough to knock me forward into Cassie when she pulled the bag toward her. The force caused her to stumble over and lose her footing. She threw her hands onto the table to try to balance.

“Don’t—” I started.

“Get off—” she said at the same time.

The leg of the table dragged harshly against the floor, a scrape that cut through the noise of the room, and then the entire thing tipped forward under our combined weight. We both lurched with it, our balance already gone, and the next second we were falling.

The rows of carefully arranged cookies scattered.

Some flipped, some snapped clean in half, others went flying off the surface entirely, skidding across the floor in streaks of frosting and crumbs as the table gave out under us and dropped.

We went down with it.

Everything tilted sideways, the room blurring at the edges as we landed half on the broken table and half on the floor, surrounded by the wreckage. Frosting smeared across my sleeve. A crushed sugar cookie cracked under my hand. Another hit the ground beside my shoulder with a defeated thud.

“Fuck me,” I muttered, staring up at the ceiling. The noise around us faded into silence.

“Me too,” Cassie whispered under her breath.