AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Holiday Pen Pal Twist

Page 45

by Becca Fall

Fine.

If there was even the smallest chance she might want me once I wasn’t sitting three desks away from her, then I’d walk away from the job without regrets.

I was beginning to suspect there wasn’t much I wouldn’t do for her.

At eight fifty-five, Janet tapped her glass at the front of the room. The sound cut through the noise just enough for the room to tilt toward her, conversation thinning in slow stages.

“Happy Holidays, everyone,” she said, holding a microphone in one hand. “There are three minutes left until the PinnacleHoliday pen pal reveal. If you participated, please open your app. Pairings drop simultaneously at nine.”

A ripple moved through the room as phones came out. Screens lit up. People performed varying degrees of casualness while actively checking something they cared about more than they wanted to admit.

Mine was already in my hand.

Across the room, Cassie was laughing at something Ben said, her head tipped slightly toward him, her glass resting loosely in her hand without her drinking from it. She looked entirely inside the moment. Bright-eyed and unaware that the night was about to divide itself into before and after.

In a few moments, that would change.

Whatever distance I had been trying to maintain had already collapsed somewhere over the past few weeks, replaced by a quieter and far more dangerous truth: I cared about what happened next way too much.

Someone near the bar started a countdown from thirty.

I focused on other numbers instead, instinctively reaching for numbers orderly enough to steady me. Five spilled eggnogs over the course of the night. Eight finance employees in attendance. Three people currently standing under the mistletoe, pretending not to notice it.

Ten seconds left.

The room picked up the countdown all at once, voices overlapping into one loud, uneven chorus, everyone invested in an outcome none of them could control.

Three.

Cassie glanced down at her phone.

Two.

My grip tightened slightly around my glass.

One.

The notification hit every phone in the room simultaneously.

The reaction came apart in pieces. Laughter from one corner. Someone swearing loudly near the bar. A sharp inhale somewhere behind me. The surprised noise people make when reality arrives half a step faster than they were prepared for.

My screen showed exactly what I already knew.

SmilingsMyFavorite. Cassie Morgan. Marketing, Floor 14.

I looked up immediately.

Across the room, her smile had already faded as she stared down at her phone, reading. Processing. Rereading.

And then her eyes lifted directly to mine.

There was surprise on her face, yes, but not shock. It settled over her like an answer rather than a revelation, the last missing piece clicking into place after she’d been carrying the question around for days.

She suspected.

The noise of the party seemed to dull around the edges. Conversations still happening, glasses clinking somewhere near the bar, Ben laughing too loudly at something unrelated, but all of it suddenly distant compared to the fact that Cassie Morgan was looking at me like she was trying to reconcile two separate versions of reality in real time.

Then she took a small step back.