AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Holiday Pen Pal Twist

Page 46

by Becca Fall

I recognized it immediately because I had seen variations of it before. In the kitchen when a conversation edged too close to honesty. Across the office when she deflected instead of pushing deeper. Cassie moved toward most things easily, but the ones that had the power to rearrange her internally…

Those she retreated from first.

Her eyes stayed locked on mine for one second longer than necessary. Long enough that the silence between us stopped feeling empty and started feeling dangerously full.

I thought, briefly, that she might walk toward me.

Instead, she looked away.

Turned.

And walked out.

The doorway swallowed her almost immediately, the mistletoe hanging overhead as she passed beneath it without slowing once.

I stayed where I was.

Around me, the room resumed itself in uneven waves. People comparing matches. Janet asking if anyone needed another drink ticket. Someone near the photo booth shouting that their pairing “made so much sense actually.” The world continued forward with astonishing indifference.

Meanwhile, my entire nervous system had narrowed itself down to the fact that Cassie had left.

I did the numbers automatically because that was what my brain did when it didn’t know where else to put the feeling.

One new job.

One last night at PinnacleTech.

One girl I couldn’t stop thinking about.

I stood there for a moment after she left.

I had imagined this reveal differently. In every version I’d thought through, there had at least been a conversation afterward. An explanation. A chance to tell her the things I hadn’t managed to fit into typed messages and half-finished interactions beside coffee machines.

Instead, there was only absence.

An ache settled behind my sternum with the unmistakable shape of regret.

Should I have followed her?

Maybe giving her space was the wrong call. Maybe I had mistaken retreat for rejection because it was easier than risking confirmation of the opposite. Maybe I had spent so much time trying to handle this carefully that I had failed to handle it honestly.

Across the room, Ben caught my eye and lifted his drink in celebration of something. I nodded automatically without hearing whatever he said.

After a while, I finished my drink and set the empty glass on the nearest table.

Then I picked up my coat.

Tonight I would clear out my desk, walk away from the job I’d wanted to leave for months, and try not to think too hard about the fact that the only part of PinnacleTech I couldn’t imagine leaving behind had just walked out the door.

And after that…

I would find out whether I had ruined the best thing that had happened to me all year.

9

CASSIE/ALEX

Cassie