AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Tell Me It’s Wrong

Page 122

by Katie Wismer

Something flutters across her face—so quick I barely catch it. “Is that all he said?”

I frown. “I know he left after that. Was out on his own with a few other kids for a year before he ended up with you.”

She nods and rolls her lips together. “It wasn’t just the parents who died that night. A little girl did too. She was five years old. Her name was Lucy.”

I suck in a sharp breath. No, he had most certainly not told me that part.

“Fletcher jumped out of the window with her to get her out, but the paramedics couldn’t resuscitate her. The smoke inhalation closed off her airway. She died on the scene.”

Last night. Fletcher had been so worried—out of his mind in a way I’d never seen before—because of the smoke. He kept asking them to check our throats…

God, that must have dug up so much for him.

I cover my mouth with my hand. “Why are you telling me this?”

“Because I’m afraid.” Her frown carves deep lines into her face, and she wrings her hands together in her lap. “I think there’s a lot in his past that he hasn’t processed. We’ve tried to help him as much as we can. And this…he won’t make it easy on you, but he needs someone. He never likes to be the one getting taken care of. He hasn’t let me in a long time. But I’m hoping he might let you.”

“You don’t think he’s coming back here,” I realize.

She shakes her head. “Dave drove to his house this morning to see if he’d gone there after the hospital.”

“Where else would he go?” I ask, but I already know the answer, don’t I?

It’s a four-hour drive to Northumberland, squarely in the middle-of-nowhere Pennsylvania. But the moment Fletcher’s mom helped me dig up the address for his old house, I jumped in the car. Luckily they agreed to watch Casey until Liam could come pick him up later in the morning.

I just hope I’m right about this.

When I finally turn into the neighborhood, I slow to a crawl and take in the houses around me. Many falling apart or boarded up. A sad park sits in the center—two swings, one of them broken, and a metal slide. All of the surrounding grass is dead.

My heart aches as I inch along, trying to picture a younger Fletcher growing up here.

It’s not that different from what my neighborhood looked like at that age.

It’s not the house I see first.

It’s his truck.

I let out the breath I’ve been holding the entire drive here.

He’s parked across the street from the shambles of what used to be his home. It’s clear it was never fixed after the fire. Condemned. Left behind to rot.

I can’t help but wonder which window it was. I’m guessing one on the side of the house. They all have boards over them now.

I park a few feet away and climb out. I don’t think he’s noticed me, not until I round to the passenger side and knock on the window.

He jumps, and his eyes soften in surprise when he sees me. He immediately unlocks the door and leans over to open it.

“Chris,” he breathes. “What are you⁠—?”

His eyes are bloodshot, and the shadows beneath them are a darkness I’ve never seen on him—and that’s saying something with the amount of sleep he’s been getting lately.

“You shouldn’t be here,” he murmurs as I climb in. “You should hate me.”

My heart cracks in half in my chest. “Fletcher.” I lay my hand on the side of his face and force him to meet my eyes. “I don’t blame you for a second.”

“This is because of me. I brought her into your lives, and I put Casey at risk⁠—”

“This isn’t your fault.” I make my voice as firm as I can manage. “Please don’t take this on. You got us both out. You’re the reason we’re okay.”