AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Tell Me It’s Wrong

Page 123

by Katie Wismer

He shakes his head a little and faces forward. A muscle in his jaw jumps, and a tear rolls down his cheek.

“Fletch,” I say quietly. “Why didn’t you tell me about Lucy?”

His eyes fall shut, and he says nothing for a long time. “I got her out,” he whispers. “I got her out, and she still died.” He hiccups, his chest rising rapidly with his breath. “I got her out. She shouldn’t have died. I got her—I got her⁠—”

“Fletcher.” I reach for him, desperately wanting to help but not knowing what to do. I touch his face, the back of his neck. He doesn’t even seem to be aware that I’m here anymore.

“I got her out,” he gasps. “I got her—I got her out. It doesn’t make sense. I got her out.”

I climb over the center console, into his lap, and take his face between my hands, forcing him to look at me.

“Breathe.”

“I got her—I got her out,” he whispers. Tears stream down his cheeks.

“I know. I know.” I wrap my arms around him and hold him as tightly as I can.

“I got her out,” he says, and it sounds like a whimper.

“You did everything you could for her. You did everything you could. It wasn’t your fault.” I press my face against his shoulder and murmur in his ear over and over. I don’t even know what I’m saying at this point, but he’s holding me back just as tightly.

“I thought you were dead,” he gasps. “I thought I lost you.”

I kiss his temple and tighten my arms around him. “You have me.”

I hold him until his breathing slows. When I pull back, I frame his face again and search his eyes. They stare back at me, and I’ve never seen him this open, this vulnerable.

This broken.

And I want so desperately to put the pieces back together for him, but I can’t fix this. It’s just the kind of pain you have to suffer through until it doesn’t hurt as much anymore.

I know nothing I can say will make this better, but I settle on “I love you.”

His eyelids shutter, and he swallows hard. “I love you,” he says roughly, and his hands mirror mine, one coming to each side of my face.

I wipe the tears from his cheeks. “Lucy—do you know where she is?”

His eyebrows pull together, and he scrunches his nose like he’s trying not to cry again. He shakes his head.

I run a hand down the back of his hair. “Would you like to go find her?”

The records aren’t that hard to find, and the cemetery is only a few blocks from the house. With no family, she was cremated and buried here among other unclaimed bodies.

I start to worry this was a very bad idea as I hold Fletcher’s hand and follow him through the rows. Maybe seeing such a small, sad burial for her will make him feel more guilty.

But when we find her, he sighs, and the tension in his shoulders seems to ease.

I gently lay down the flowers we picked up on the way, then turn my face as I rise to my feet so Fletcher can’t see the tears already streaming down my cheeks.

He clears his throat, lowers to a knee, and runs his fingers over the tiny stone in the ground. “Hey, Goose.”

I press my lips together, the tears coming in earnest now.

“You were always asking when I was finally going to get a girlfriend,” he continues, a small smile in his voice. “So I brought someone to meet you. This is Christine.”

“Hi, Lucy,” I murmur.

“I want you to know that I’ve never stopped thinking about you. I’m sorry I didn’t make it here before now.”